This is the farthest thing you’ll find from Nutter Butter, mass-produced nonsense. Yes, I use only high-quality peanut butter. Yes I use only unsalted butter, real vanilla, and brown sugar. No, I never skimp on quality, and no I’ll never deliver poor quality peanut butter treats. If you like all things sweet, this is definitely a must for your palate. There are very pronounced pieces of ground peanuts throughout the surface of each cookie.